Critique is a gift you give another designer. Make it one worth getting.
Crit works because everyone gives as much as they take. These four rules keep it useful.
How it works
Three steps, both ways
Share
Post up to four images, a short brief, and the questions you want answered.
Critique
Designers answer in three parts: what works, what to focus on, and a question back. It appears under the post, where the designer and others can reply.
Give back
Mark the critiques that helped, then crit someone else. Posts with no feedback show first.
The rules
For everyone, every time
- 01
Be specific
Point at the thing. "The dial's red pulls focus from the light" helps; "nice colours" doesn't.
- 02
Critique the work, not the person
Talk about the design and its choices. Kind and honest are not opposites.
- 03
Answer what they asked
The designer told you what they're unsure of. Start there before anything else.
- 04
Give as much as you get
For every post you share, crit at least two others. First crits matter most.
Keeping it kind
Clean language, and a Report button
No explicit language
Swear words and slurs are blocked as you type, and moderators are told when someone tries.
Report what breaks the rules
Every post, critique and reply has a Report link. Three reports hide it until a moderator decides.
Delete your own
You can delete your own posts, critiques and replies at any time. Accounts that break the rules can be banned.
What good looks like
The same thought, twice
Not helpful
"Love it! Maybe make it more modern?"
Helpful
"The handles tie the set together. The server's blade feels generic next to the peel; try borrowing its front curve so the metal parts match too."